Agency revgen is broken

Apr 25, 2023

TL:DR

A common challenge among agencies is their over-reliance on referrals and heroic efforts from owners when leads dry up. This creates a host of downstream issues like poor utilization rates, diminishing margins, and morale challenges.

The fix lies in building repeatable leadgen/sales systems into the agency’s DNA.

Start with focused outreach to a well-defined niche. Then employ dedicated team members to handle outreach and leadgen. Finally, build your marketing content pillars around what’s top-of-mind for that niche.

A rollercoaster of frustration

I’ve done a bit of research on digital shops over the last eight years, and something that continually comes up is the boom/bust cycle of sales.

It’s perfectly normal to have lead volume fluctuate with the market, but the way most shops generate revenue is unreliable.

Every time I’ve asked, “how do you generate new leads” in a survey, the vast majority respond with “referrals.”

While they can be a great source of growth, too many shops are overly reliant on them.

80% referrals, 10% organic search, and 10% Clutch isn’t a reliable way to grow a shop, especially when the market gets choppy.

Sales during recessions

If the goal is to have steady growth, regardless of market conditions, we have to examine how revgen works during good times and bad.

The referral strategy tends to work well during solid economic times, but when a recession hits, or the market becomes unstable, referrals dry up. This leaves agencies scrambling to find new leads and relying on the heroic efforts of owners to fill the pipeline.

The consequences of this approach are significant.

Poor utilization rates, reduced profit margins, and plummeting morale are some of the downstream problems that arise from inconsistent revenue.

A framework for sustainable growth

To avoid this rollercoaster of frustration and build a more predictable and sustainable revgen process, owners must embed a lead generation and sales system into the core of their agency operations.

The following three tactics can help achieve this:

  • Identify a niche: Concentrate on a particular target market or industry and develop expertise in their needs, challenges, and objectives. This makes the next two more effective.
  • Dedicate resources: Allocate team members exclusively to outreach and lead generation activities, ensuring consistency in top-of-funnel initiatives and mitigating referral shortages during challenging times.
  • Targeted content: Design marketing materials and content pillars that cater to the specific needs and concerns of your target niche. Account-based marketing (ABM) strategies can be particularly effective in this context, especially when combined with persistent, targeted outreach efforts.

By adopting this framework, owners can establish a robust and sustainable lead generation and sales system that will enable them to navigate market fluctuations and deliver reliable growth.

A more complete revgen guide

I’m working on a full rewrite of our Repeatable Revgen Guide so this is all very top-of-mind for me lately.

As we see more and more headlines of slowing economic growth, it seems pertinent to get this highlight version out now. The niche, dedicated leadgen team members, and targeted content are a great summation of how to build a repeatable revgen system.

Since it’s still in the works, what would you like to see covered in an updated revgen guide?

What have you been successful with?

What do you want more clarity around?

State of Digital Services Survey Closes Friday

Don’t forget: Through Friday, we’re accepting responses for this year’s State of Digital Services survey!

All participants get access to the full report that covers:

  • AI implementation rates
  • Average revenue growth rates
  • Agency profitability
  • Utilization rates
  • Hourly rate data
  • Pricing models
  • Service mix including most profitable services
  • Average number of clients and client tenure
  • Employee retention strategies
  • Key trends shaping the industry
  • And more!

So far, it’s taking <15min on average. Just make sure you have easy access to your 2022 financial and team data before starting.

Related Articles

Hold on to Your Seniors

Hold on to Your Seniors

TL;DR SURVEY CLOSING: The State of Digital Services 2026 survey closes Monday, 3/9. Be sure to participate before then to get access to the full report and live readout webinar. Agencies have largely stopped hiring entry-level and junior talent since 2022-23. That gap will show up later as a shortage of mid-level and senior practitioners. At the same time, AI is absorbing the kind of repetitive production work juniors used to do across coding, marketing, and design. Senior talent remains…

read more
What’s Your Minimum Effective Engagement?

What’s Your Minimum Effective Engagement?

TL;DR The 2026 State of Digital Services Survey is live! Participate and get the results for free. We received more interest than expected in our new Revgen 2.0 service, so we will need to move to a waitlist for now. Join the list if you’d like to spend time on something OTHER than constant revgen challenges. AI is increasing pricing pressure, and discounting or “value engineering” scope often leaves clients with work that doesn’t deliver the outcome they want. A Minimum Effective Engagement…

read more
Building Reliable Revgen Machines

Building Reliable Revgen Machines

Building Reliable Revgen Machines Progress meetings suck when you’re missing targets. They suck even more when it happens multiple times in a row. We’ve seen too many leadership teams have these conversations quarter after quarter for years now. So, we’re designing a new service to help agency teams quickly find and fix key revgen issues. It includes a full review of an agency’s: Leadership vision, alignment, and goals Positioninig Roles and responsibilities Brand Service mix Pricing…

read more

Our latest insights on running digital agencies

Exclusive research opportunities, thoughts, and advice on the digital agency industry every two weeks.

"Best / most valuable updates from anyone in ages. I get hit up soooooo much, keep this kind of newsletter / value up."

Wil Reynolds

CEO, Seer Interactive

Contact us

Share This